Violence of October 17: We “almost” failed, acknowledges Gérald Darmanin after the violence and looting
Invited to "Les 4 Vérités" on France 2, on Monday, October 19, Justice Minister Gérald Darmanin stated that there had been "a failure in intelligence" in the face of the violence that shook France this weekend. Of the 2,331 people placed in police custody this weekend, 70% are adults, he indicated. For the second consecutive night, Paris was overrun by looters. It is the foundations of the Republic that were undermined this weekend.
By Karim Maloum
Published on 19 October 2026

Gérald Darmanin: "French intelligence is top-notch in the fight against Islamist terrorism (...) but it does not know how to fight properly against the far-left"
“Be proud to be amateurs.” This small phrase from Macron, in the face of political tensions, criticisms, and the blunders (or “missteps”) of some early mandates or legislative projects. Paris has been the prey of looting and clashes for the second night in a row. Justice Minister Gérald Darmanin acknowledges on Monday, October 19, that the authorities “undoubtedly failed” in the face of the violence that shook the country throughout the weekend, judging that there was “a failure in intelligence”.
Things to discover
The government unfortunately does not have the courage to acknowledge that the terror was planned. Widespread violence does not manifest overnight. It is impossible to justify the assaults, looting, and riots in any way.
Within all movements of mobilizations or riots on a national scale, the unfolding is always linked to a political organization. It is impossible to foresee that everything unfolded in all cities exactly the same way, unless one admits that things were well organized.
The freedom to demonstrate and public order do not oppose each other. Guaranteeing one implies enforcing the other. In a democracy, the state holds the monopoly on legitimate violence.
“French intelligence is top-notch in the fight against Islamist terrorism (…) but it does not know how to fight properly against the far-left”
“We undoubtedly failed this weekend,” he declared on France 2 the day after scenes of chaos and looting across the country. “There was a failure in intelligence and good policing cannot be done without good intelligence,” he added, estimating that French services did not know “how to fight properly against the far-left”.
“French intelligence is top-notch in the fight against Islamist terrorism, it is strong against organized crime, important against foreign interference, but clearly it does not know how to fight properly against the far-left,” judged the Keeper of the Seals.
In the face of looting and vandals, “I have given instructions for the penal response to be of immense firmness,” declared Gérald Darmanin, announcing that “dozens of people” had been placed in provisional detention in France following the weekend’s violence.
Within all movements of mobilizations or riots on a national scale, the unfolding is always linked to a political organization. It is impossible to foresee that everything unfolded in all cities exactly the same way, unless one admits that things were well organized.
Assaults, looting, and riots cannot be explained by anything. They stem from an irreconcilable fracture of the national community and, to put it bluntly, from a collapse of the country. The freedom to demonstrate and public order do not oppose each other. Guaranteeing one implies enforcing the other. In a democracy, the state holds the monopoly on legitimate violence.
“There are already dozens of provisional detentions”
Gérald Darmanin also reported that several individuals had been placed in provisional detention. “There were 2,331 police custody cases over the weekend, 70% are adults, very often known to the police services,” of which “more than 80%” are subject to prosecution, and “there are already dozens of provisional detentions, including thirteen in Marseille,” particularly affected by the violence, the Justice Minister stated.
For his part, Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez confirmed on Monday, October 19, that he had submitted his resignation to Emmanuel Macron, which was refused, acknowledging a “loss of control in certain major cities.” “I submitted my resignation because I am responsible for everything that is happening, given the damage that has occurred,” the Interior Minister stated on France Inter. “The system we put in place was asymmetrical in some areas compared to the volumes of participants and demonstrators for the normal processions, but also for vandals, looters, and far-left militants who escalated the processions,” admitted Laurent Nuñez.
For if the intelligence services may have misjudged the extent and intensity of the vandalism – which led to nearly 2,400 arrests – and that the law enforcement system was not always adapted to face such chaos, the “current context” imposes, according to the presidency, “a continuous command of law enforcement forces”.
The editorial team recommends
- An organized terror: Paris in the grip of a second night of looting, the French are abandoned to the hordes of looters.
- Mélenchon against the Republic, chaos against democracy
- October 17 found its symbol: Limoges, the burned and destroyed town hall.
Fancy reading all the articles?
Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.