A book to read: Machine Life. Why and how to resist AI, by Gaultier Bès
Jacob Coxon, a resigning engineer from the company Anthropic specializing in training AI models, made headlines in September 2026 by warning of an AI that "could kill us all by the end of the decade." We can already see the four horsemen of the Apocalypse on the horizon. Gaultier Bès, however, a great connoisseur of biblical matters, does not follow this path. But what he says is no less dire: the Apocalypse is not to come, for the destruction of life and humanity has already begun.
By Denis Collin
Published on 12 September 2026

Gaultier Bès is part of a long-standing tradition of criticism of technology.
Gaultier Bès is not a computer scientist. He practices the noble profession of a professor of literature (of fine literature). He was one of the animators of the magazine Limite, which was Catholic, ecological, and anti-consumerist, and is now defunct. He is primarily a defender of humanism. His analysis of AI is part of a general critique of digitization and the networking of all social relations. It carries much more weight than the usual critiques of AI, which are too often inspired by the Matrix scenario.
Things to discover
Gaultier Bès is part of a long-standing tradition of criticism of technology – one thinks of Jacques Ellul – and of acceleration – here one can refer to Hartmunt Rosa – of which AI is only the ultimate development (for now). AI functions like a vast enterprise of administering narcotics: “it is high time to resist artificial paradises, to tear our existences from the attraction of the cyborg and the machines of living, in short, to reconnect with the living.” (18). “We must slow down,” he adds. Indeed, we are like drugged by an acceleration of innovations that prevents us from thinking. This acceleration is merely the acceleration of the march towards catastrophe.
Ecological catastrophe first. Here the author takes up data that is now widely disseminated on the consumption of water, energy, and raw materials by AI and its consequences on our environment, that is, on our vital milieu. He denounces this “technological drunkenness” that leads us to the destruction of the conditions for human life, “For AI, decidedly, is not the rationalization of the real, but the optimization of catastrophe.” (61)
Undoubtedly unknowingly, the author follows the line of reasoning of Marx who says that capital destroys the two sources of wealth, the Earth and labor. Thus he devotes a chapter to “stolen labor”: AI not only threatens employment on a massive scale, but it also empties work of all meaning and will not allow us to live the carefree life of the Arcadian shepherds; rather, its first use will be the maximum exploitation of the workers who remain, but under the surveillance of an AI (think Amazon). This issue is old; the destruction of trades in favor of a growing parasitic bureaucracy has already been analyzed by David Graeber, whom the author cites. “A carpenter, a nurse, a baker, a magistrate, an accountant, each understands the meaning and reason for being, but a ‘community manager’, a ‘media training manager’, a ‘public relations specialist’, a ‘human resources consultant’, ‘CEO’, ‘business adviser’, ‘managing partner’ and other ‘bullshit works’ that LinkedIn is full of?” (83) The promises of the AI gurus who announce a society freed from the burden of work are poisons. We remember Hannah Arendt’s prediction in The Human Condition, announcing the arrival of a society of workers without work, “one cannot imagine anything worse.” Idleness is not bad in itself; it is bad when it is not used to elevate man or to allow him to reconnect with nature. But this is not the creative idleness of the Ancients that the merchants of AI promise us. Let us never forget that “Behind every automaton, behind every screen, there is less a liberated worker than a cynical billionaire.” (91)
Nature, labor, is also, and perhaps above all, the thought that AI ravages. Here again, things did not start with chatGPT. Gaultier Bès reminds us: “From De Gaulle to Sarkozy, researchers had noted a decrease in lexical richness and sentence length. Already, in a completely different context, the Jewish philosopher Victor Klemperer said, in 1947, of the ‘Language of the Third Reich’, simplified to the extreme and monotonous, that it was ‘all-powerful as well as poor, and all-powerful precisely because of its poverty.’ The reduction of language to propaganda, of thought to slogan, that is to say to the mechanical, unthought cry, evolves according to the technologies in place – radio the day before yesterday, the telescreen in 1984, advertising marketing yesterday, chatbots today… – but it is always a semantic and syntactic impoverishment.” AI organizes, structures this weakening and normalization of language, not directly, but indirectly by allowing human brains to stop thinking. Just as GPS makes one lose their sense of direction, AI makes one lose their sense of reflection and, by eliminating effort, prevents young minds from forging themselves. AI is not “intelligent”; it is merely calculative and empties the words it produces of all meaning. The reason is simple: AI does not feel, for it is not alive and has neither flesh, nor sensations, nor feelings, nor anything that constitutes human intelligence. Bès’s reflections, himself a teacher, on education should be read carefully, for it is the generations to come who are undergoing a brainwashing that is all the more effective because it is appetizing. They will succeed in their studies, present theses of acceptable quality, but they themselves will know nothing. The process is already well underway.
The fourth disaster of AI is the parasitism of democracy. False images, false information, all kinds of disinformation, and especially widespread surveillance, this is what is already underway. The CEO of Oracle (whose JavaScript software is practically on all computers) expressed it this way: “Citizens will behave better because we record and report everything that happens.” (cited p.157) The author does not forget to trace back to the root: Tech is in reality only the continuation of capitalist expansion and its war on the living by other means, and AI is the latest fashionable instrument of domination. For AI is capitalism incarnate, if one dares say so.
In conclusion, the author proposes resistance to AI, by all means he says, except violence against people, and he evokes the mythical General Ludd, in whose name the English Luddites broke the machines that deprived workers of their jobs. Having published nearly two years ago a book entitled Becoming Machines (Max Milo editions), I find myself largely in agreement with Gaultier Bès’s work, which has the advantage of being accessible to any serious reader and requires neither technical knowledge nor philosophical knowledge. In reading this book, I think of the verses of Aragon, “the one who believed in heaven and the one who did not believe in it,” for we are close to each other on the most essential questions and his call to reconnect with the humanist tradition must be heard.
D. C.
The Mechanical Life. Why and How to Resist AI, by Gaultier Bès, Desclée de Brower editions
The editorial team recommends
Fancy reading all the articles?
Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.