Threats to freedom of expression: the totalitarian mayor Ali Rabeh wants to make the theory of the “great replacement” “illegal” by amending the 1881 law on press freedom.
The magazine Rupture has always demonstrated a constant commitment to freedom of opinion within the legal framework and against totalitarianism, particularly Islamists. After the racist attack in Trappes and La Verrière, Mayor Ali Rabeh proposes to make the theory of the great replacement illegal, notably by amending the 1881 law on press freedom. Totalitarians always attack press freedom. It is distressing to take advantage of an abominable crime that occurred in Trappes to advance one's totalitarian ideology, close to that of Islamists.
By Karim Maloum
Published on 30 October 2026
Après l’attentat raciste à Trappes et à La Verrière, le maire Ali Rabeh propose de rendre illégale la théorie du grand remplacement, notamment en modifiant la loi sur la liberté de la presse de 1881.
— France Inter (@franceinter) October 30, 2026
➡️ https://t.co/57nHpTNY1D pic.twitter.com/WkABfDaMIK
Repeated threats from Ali Rabeh against freedom of expression are unacceptable in a democracy.
Totalitarians are all the same. Press freedom is the enemy they have assigned themselves. They must quickly gag and prevent the press. From the very first minutes of the terrorist attack in Trappes, which resulted in one death and seven injuries, the Mayor of Trappes condemned the terrorist act, but he hurried to provide an ideological explanation…Islamist. For him, it is an Islamophobic act.
Things to discover
It should be noted that the term “Islamophobia” is used to confuse anti-Arab racism with criticism of a religion in order to criminalize the former, and to remember that the accusation of “Islamophobia” primarily harms the one who is accused. Criticism of the retrograde practices of a religious vision is not a crime but an opinion, while the expression of racism is not an opinion but a crime.
The crime of blasphemy was abolished on July 29, 1881, in France, where one can criticize religions. Blasphemy is a republican right. Racism concerns individuals and not religion. However, the Mayor of Trappes, in line with a totalitarian ideology, mocks the history of France and adopts the discourse of Islamists.
There is freedom of expression for all opinions, except those that are contrary to the law. For the grieving mayor, Ali Rabeh (Génération.s), it is necessary to make the theory of the “great replacement” illegal in the law, which he claims is shared by the assailant. This theory, introduced by Renaud Camus, claims that “the white population” would be replaced by “mass immigration.” While there are already provisions that prevent incitement to racial hatred, for the elected official, they remain “insufficient.”
Repeated threats from Ali Rabeh against freedom of expression are unacceptable in a democracy
Democracy places paramount importance on press freedom, which becomes an essential virtue. Under the IV and V Republics, the expression of the press is free. However, a mayor wishes, if his friends are in power, to make changes to the 1881 law.
A week after the racist attack in Trappes (Yvelines), a tribute will be held in the late afternoon in the city for Pengo Bossio Wangi, the 26-year-old killed by Kevin T., as well as for the seven injured. The shooter, who admitted to having “specifically targeted people (…) of Muslim or African or North African descent,” was charged on Thursday and placed in provisional detention.
“The law needs to be toughened,” he demands into the microphone of France Inter. According to him, it is not about “banning ideas,” but rather about “making illegal the speech of those who consider there is an enemy within and who explain, by pointing to a whole part of the population, that they are invaders.” Elected mayor since 2021, he calls for “modifying the Constitution” for this purpose.
It is preferable not to replace the battle of ideas with prohibitions. Introduced in 2010 by French writer Renaud Camus, this theory is refuted by most scientists but enjoys great success in far-right circles in France and elsewhere in the world.
An infringement on press freedom within the National Assembly adds to the gravity of the situation. A CNews team excluded from an event – a press conference by the Mayor of Trappes – in the temple of French democracy is alarming, and it is particularly surprising and shocking that there has been no adequate reaction from institutions and the political class.
Repeated threats from Ali Rabeh against freedom of expression are unacceptable in a democracy.
The editorial team recommends
Fancy reading all the articles?
Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.