He refused to marry a foreigner under OQTF: Robert Ménard wants to use a statement from Emmanuel Macron in court.
For Robert Ménard, the matter will be settled in court. After rejecting a plea deal last February, Robert Ménard will be tried on September 30 before the correctional court in Montpellier. In 2025, the mayor of Béziers had questioned Emmanuel Macron on TF1 about this situation. The president then acknowledged the "absurd" nature of the case and spoke of a "common sense debate". Statements that Robert Ménard now intends to bring back to the center of his defense.
By Karim Maloum
Published on 29 September 2026

Refusal to marry a man under OQTF, media political witnesses, and the risk of ineligibility: the high-stakes trial of Béziers mayor Robert Ménard. The case had sparked controversy at the highest level, as even Emmanuel Macron described, in 2025, the situation of mayors being required to marry individuals in an irregular situation as “absurd”.
Things to discover
For Robert Ménard, the matter will be settled in court. After rejecting a plea deal last February, Robert Ménard will be tried on September 30 before the correctional court in Montpellier.
For his refusal, considered a form of “disobedience” under current law, Robert Ménard risks five years of imprisonment, a €75,000 fine, and a penalty of ineligibility. “Since it’s absurd, I hope he will come to tell the judges that it’s an absurd situation,” he presses.
In July 2023, Robert Ménard refused to celebrate the union between a French woman and this man in an irregular situation. The public prosecutor then determined that there were not enough elements to suspect a fraudulent marriage and reminded that the right to marry does not depend on the legality of residency.
Since then, Robert Ménard has made this case a political battle, denouncing a contradiction between the obligations imposed on mayors and the deportation policy pursued by the State.
The mayor faces up to five years in prison and a €75,000 fine, as well as a potential additional penalty of ineligibility. These are maximum penalties, with the court still needing to rule on his guilt and then, if applicable, on the sanction. “It’s mainly the ineligibility that I fear because I did not apply the law,” said Robert Ménard, re-elected for a third term.
Robert Ménard justifies his decision by blaming the State: “It has decreed an obligation to leave the territory and it does not enforce it. I was not going to marry someone who is obliged to leave the territory.” The mayor of Béziers had asked Emmanuel Macron to come testify at his trial, but the head of state will not attend.
A bill under discussion
Summoned to the Montpellier court for the first time in February 2025, Robert Ménard rejected the “plea deal” that was offered to him, resulting in the case being referred to the correctional court. He notably risks a penalty of ineligibility, a prospect he dreads as he has just been re-elected as head of Béziers.
A bill aimed at prohibiting marriages for individuals in an irregular situation in France is currently in the hands of the Law Commission of the National Assembly.
In France, the number of individuals in an irregular situation is estimated to be between 600,000 and 900,000 people. It is impossible to provide an exact figure as these individuals live outside official administrative circuits.
There is therefore a problem of relations between France and the countries of origin of individuals under OQTF. There is also a legal problem.
Fancy reading all the articles?
Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.