For the memory of Paty and Bernard, for Secularism, let us fight!
Samuel Paty, through the teaching of History, was an architect of Public Instruction, of Civic Education, while Dominique Bernard, who taught Literature, provided minds with the weapons of emancipation, the path to Freedom. It is no coincidence that they were targeted.
By Jean-Baptiste Chikhi-Budjeia
Published on 16 October 2026

The barbaric torture endured by Samuel Paty should have been the last straw. Three years after the macabre event, a fanatic struck again and took the life of another teacher, Dominique Bernard.
“When the knight de La Barre, grandson of a lieutenant general of the armies, a young man of great spirit and great hope, but having all the recklessness of a wild youth, was convicted of having sung impious songs, and even of having passed in front of a procession of Capuchins without having removed his hat, the judges of Abbeville, people comparable to Roman senators, ordered not only that his tongue be torn out, that his hand be cut off, and that his body be burned slowly; but they also subjected him to torture to find out how many songs he had sung, and how many processions he had seen pass, with his hat on his head[1].”
Thus did Voltaire describe the torture of the knight de La Barre, in his Philosophical Dictionary. He also defined fanaticism in the following terms: “Fanaticism is to superstition what transport is to fever, what rage is to anger. He who has ecstasies, visions, who takes dreams for realities, and his imaginations for prophecies, is an enthusiast; he who supports his madness with murder is a fanatic. […]”
Things to discover
As we would have preferred to write that these horrors, in France, were a dark memory, a stigma reminding our minds that the secular struggle, that for the emancipation of individuals establishing just laws in a free republic, rid of religious tutelage, superstition, and fundamentalism commanding consciences, had been necessary. Freedom, even the freedom to think for oneself, had been wrested, conquered through great struggles. But here we are, after the attacks and the abominable murders committed since 2012, at Ozar Hatorah, at Charlie Hebdo, at the Hyper Cacher, at the Bataclan, on the Promenade des Anglais, … (the list is too long), fanatical blood crimes committed by Allah’s enraged, with politicians not fully grasping the enemy’s intentions, fanaticism struck again, brutally taking two lives.
It was in the heart of the sanctuary of republican France, its School, that the wound was inflicted. On October 16, 2020, Samuel Paty, a history teacher in love with freedom, concerned with raising the future citizens who followed his classes, was decapitated, yes, decapitated, on the soil of the Homeland of the Rights of Man and Citizen.
One in two teachers self-censors, particularly in History, Literature, or Life and Earth Sciences
The teacher wishing to convey that quintessentially French impertinence foundational to freedom, which any person who cherishes it can embrace, no matter where they come from, showed his students caricatures, including those of the prophet Muhammad published long ago by Charlie Hebdo. Let it be said without ambiguity: on the soil of the French Republic where Clermont-Tonnerre proclaimed “Everything must be refused to the Jews as a nation and everything granted to the Jews as individuals,” and where the Third Republic expelled Catholic religious congregations with the support of the army, Islam (without even an “-ism”) should not benefit from any preferential treatment. It should not be spared from criticism, philosophical or intellectual attacks, even if shocking or violent.
Unfortunately, an association led by extremists, the CCIF, repeatedly denounced by secular associations for what it was, launched a campaign fueled by a furious preacher. The “presentable” extremists armed, through their archaic, retrograde, and enraged discourse, in the France heir to the Enlightenment and the French Revolution, the arm of the fanatic! They brandished this bloodied word, soaked in the most obscure superstition, “Islamophobia,” a new way of saying without expressing it in these terms, “crime of blasphemy,” which had been effectively abolished by Article 10 of the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen, yet joyfully chanted by many activists and personalities of the woke left won over to multiculturalism, which carries within it the seeds of war of all against all.
Everything could have been stopped by the authorities, had they shown themselves worthy of our struggles that some believed were past, had they shown themselves worthy of the heralds of this Republic charging for freedom, sabers drawn against superstition, fundamentalism, and fanaticism, had they shown themselves worthy of the Black Hussars of old. No, the well-documented investigation by David Di Nota[2] shows us how the rectoral administration was preparing to blame Samuel Paty, how colleagues turned their backs on him and thereby violated the memory and legacy of those of whom they are the custodians. The teaching body, predominantly on the left, unfortunately reminds us too often how it has betrayed its struggles and historical victories to wallow in the arms of the dregs of humanity: the Muslim Brotherhood, the Salafists.
The barbaric torture endured by Samuel Paty, after eleven days of moral torture, should have been the last straw – if one were to admit that the previous ones were not already… Nevertheless, the usual, the indecent, the criminals “yes but” were once again chanted. And three years after the macabre event, almost to the day, a fanatic struck again and took the life, on October 13, of another teacher, this time of Literature, Dominique Bernard. This time, it was within the very walls of the School – the capital letter is intentional – that blood was shed!
Samuel Paty, through the teaching of History, was an architect of Public Instruction, of Civic Education, while Dominique Bernard, who taught Literature, provided minds with the weapons of emancipation, the path to Freedom. It is no coincidence that they were targeted. Let us note that just a few years after these two fanatical crimes, while the State should have terrorized the terrorists, it is the teaching body that trembles. One in two teachers self-censors, particularly in History, Literature, or Life and Earth Sciences.
Universalism is the honor of republican France, cosmopolitanism a fact that should not be confused with communitarianism
Fundamentalism is the breeding ground for fanaticism, and the complacency it enjoys fosters the feeling of impunity of those who, in mosques controlled by the Muslim Brotherhood or Salafists, preach hateful and seditious discourses. Why does the State not recall, for example, Article 35 of the 1905 law?
“If a speech pronounced or a written document displayed or distributed publicly in places where worship is exercised contains a direct provocation to resist the execution of laws or legal acts of public authority or tends to incite or arm a part of the citizens against others, the minister of worship who is guilty of it is punished by five years of imprisonment and a fine of €75,000, without prejudice [= without counting] the penalties for complicity in the event that the provocation is followed by a sedition, revolt, or civil war.”
No, since 1989, despite some attempts by strong personalities even in recent governments, it must be acknowledged that what stands out are acts of weakness (Lionel Jospin in the veil affairs of Créteil and Creil), scandalous words (Nicolas Sarkozy placing the morality of the teacher below that of the pastor), and permanent ambivalences (of which Emmanuel Macron has become the champion, even wanting to reweave the link between France and the Church).
Universalism is the honor of republican France, cosmopolitanism a fact that should not be confused with communitarianism. As for tolerance, a word overused that we should return to its roots, it cannot be used as a pretext to accept the intolerable. So, let us send our thoughts to the families of Samuel Paty and Dominique Bernard, keeping in mind that we are engaged in a life-and-death struggle against obscurantism and what we must seize is neither unreasonable calls for accommodations from the late slaughterhouse of secularism, nor the crass collaborationism carried by the “total left,” but the exhortation of Clemenceau in… 1875, and terribly current:
“The great affair to come is the victory of republican law over religious dogma, of human rights over the rights of God!”
[1] Voltaire, Philosophical Dictionary, 1769 edition.
[2] David Di Nota, I Executed a Dog from Hell. Report on the Assassination of Samuel Paty, Paris, Le Cherche-Midi, 2021.
Fancy reading all the articles?
Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.