High school crisis: the discomfort in culture

The crisis that saw the blockade of several hundred high schools, violent clashes (over 200 high school students, more than 700 police officers injured, and nearly a hundred principals and teaching staff assaulted, threatened, and sometimes injured) seems to be easing as I write these lines.

By Denis Collin

Published on 12 October 2026

High school crisis: the discomfort in culture

The unsanitary and poorly insulated premises: this is not the case in all high schools, and new high schools have not been spared by the vandals.

This movement of high school students has sparked two types of discourse: for some, it was a healthy revolt of youth against the degradation of study conditions; for others, it was an attempt to manipulate the youth during this pre-electoral period. There is some truth in all of this, and I understand that those who were 20 years old or younger in May 1968 feel rather sympathetic towards these young people who remind them of their own youth. Already having to endure dismissive “OK, boomer!” remarks, being called a “old fool” is not something one resigns oneself to easily. However, it seems necessary to understand fundamentally what is at play in this movement of youth that seems to have severed ties with previous generations.

Janus and Nihilism

The movement of high school students is similar to the god Janus. It has a reasonable face: reasonable demands (that absent teachers be replaced and that the minimum hygiene standards of high school premises be respected) and, on the other hand, we have well-organized vandals, prepared for confrontation and acting masked with Hamas flags. The “old-timers” know well that demonstrations have always faced vandals, more or less manipulated by various organizations. From the “Katangais”, thugs to whom some thought it wise to subcontract the occupation of the Sorbonne in 1968, to the “autonomists” and “black blocs”, it’s always the same scenario: groups of “lumpen” and paid provocateurs, sometimes from the public service (!), conveniently come to vandalize and discredit the social movement.

In the past, union or political order services took care of settling accounts with the “provocateurs”. But the gradual disappearance of the old labor movement leaves the field open to vandals. We try to distinguish the good serious students from the vandals, but the boundary is often very blurry, and we reassure ourselves by wanting, like Charlemagne, to put the good students (protesters, but peaceful) on one side and the bad students (who have become delinquents) on the other. There is a continuum between the one who blocks the high school for the satisfaction of his just demands and the one who sets fire to the high school, douses a principal with gasoline, or organizes the beating of a trainee police officer.

In 2024, Italian philosopher Umberto Galimberti published a very interesting book titled L’ospite inquietante. Il nichilismo e i giovanni (Feltrinelli, The Unsettling Guest. Nihilism and Youth). Galimberti makes a diagnosis that is increasingly widely accepted: young people are not doing well. And this is not about the traditional existential crises that characterize adolescence, but rather a profound cultural crisis. Nihilism, according to Nietzsche, is “the most unsettling of all guests at our door.” A terse definition can be found in the Posthumous Fragments: “Nihilism: lacks the end; lacks the answer to the question ‘why’. What does nihilism mean: that supreme values lose all value.” That there is no longer an end is particularly evident: religious belief has massively collapsed, the last great Christian heresy, Marxism, is dead.

No future! In place of everything that can elevate man above himself, a rather repugnant utilitarianism imposes itself as the “philosophical” complement of consumer society, this new form of fetishism. “Deconstruction,” in all its variants, deconstructs the meaning of life. Life itself becomes “mechanical life” (see my review of Gaultier Bès’ book). Under the domination of nihilism, the “last man” is invited to wallow in a cheap hedonism. All the evolutions of the school, the famous “reforms”, contribute to making the young generation so many examples of the “last man”. One can also understand that in reaction, certain manifestations of religious resurgence occur, sometimes singularly retrograde.

Implosion of the School Institution

The liquidation of classical culture is concomitant with the liquidation of education itself. Since Jospin put “the student at the center”, we have learned that it is up to the student to construct his own knowledge. Teachers have nothing to transmit to him; they have become “technicians” who must help the student in this self-learning. In fact, the school no longer deals with students (that is, humans who must elevate themselves), and it is no longer necessary for there to be masters – those who are higher, magis – and have authority, that is to say, this capacity to enhance, to return to the Latin etymology.

These brilliant reforms, vigorously applied by both right and left governments, united in the desire to render youth illiterate, with the complicity of the main teachers’ unions and parents’ associations, parents who have also given up on raising their offspring. Commentators and representatives often refer to high school students as “children”, and children must be cared for by “moms”, according to the prevailing terms…

How do children become adults? By liquidating their Oedipus, Freud would say. But to liquidate one’s Oedipus, the adolescent must be able to confront the authority of an adult, in this case a father (or any other father figure). But the father is gradually being eliminated. The child without a “re-father” negotiates contracts with his parent-friend. Marcuse had already noted in his reflections on repressive desublimation that the absence of resistance to the child’s impulses prevented him from building himself. But one must explode at some point, and one explodes like little children by breaking everything. The “blocking of the high school” is not a method of struggle; it is the will to impose one’s will and to break the high school. This is why democracy – voting on whether to strike or not – has become an unbearable hindrance to the impulse to act.

Under the guise of non-repressive education (positive!), the baby-boom generation and the following ones sought the love of their children. Previously, children were taught “you shall honor your father and mother”, and now parents repeat: “I absolutely do not want to lose my children’s love.” So, frustration is out! While all education is the learning of frustration, with the right dose: too much frustration creates massive neuroses (think of the type of education still dominant in many Muslim communities), but the absence of frustration inevitably drives one mad as well. When desire is satisfied immediately, it calls for another desire without delay.

The beautiful toy must be broken for another toy to be desired. In reality, non-repressive education is the worst repressive education; it aims to saturate the faculty of desire, to preempt all expectations, to occupy all moments that could possibly be unoccupied. We have not skimped! From the first consoles and pocket electronic games to smartphones and tablets, everything that could capture attention has been provided without hesitation. The example of tablets is revealing: everyone knows they have no educational value, quite the opposite. But local councils have spent a lot of money distributing them to every middle school student. Drug dealers operate in this way: they start by distributing the stuff for free, and when the young client is hooked, he has to pay up.

To Get Back on Track, Radical Transformations Are Needed

Everything happens as if we had systematically organized the rupture between generations, carefully isolating the young from the old, creating for them a “world of their own”, in line with the expectations of software and “high tech” hardware merchants. Transmission has been rendered impossible by the combined action of American-Chinese business, educational reforms, and transformations in family relationships. For this, there is no need to invoke a conspiracy. Things have happened spontaneously, following the path of least resistance of the capitalist mode of production, which ruthlessly destroys all human community and produces individuals who are all alike and interchangeable.

One of the factors that crystallized the crisis of high schools is the implementation of the ban on the use of mobile phones within school premises! But a set of disparate demands has combined. The unsanitary and poorly insulated premises: this is not the case in all high schools, and new high schools have not been spared by the vandals. The lack of teachers: it is evident since the ministry has organized the elimination of 4000 teaching positions and made it impossible to replace sick teachers. But when one knows the joy that greets the announcement of a teacher’s absence and when one knows that absenteeism (absence without reason) is roughly 4% at the beginning of the year and 14% at the end of the year, it is hard not to laugh at the demand “we want teachers”.

Let us add to this the increasing number of teachers who literally can no longer teach, due to the chaos and general inattention of the students. I am not talking here about the one who, when questioned about an ongoing assignment, responds to his teacher: “Stop bothering me!” and receives only a “conciliation commission” (sic) before which he complains of being “harassed” for spelling by his teacher… There is surely a lack of teachers, but fundamentally, a significant increase in the number of teachers will have the effect of a band-aid on a wooden leg! Contrary to what some unions think, this is not a question of resources, but a deep crisis that is ravaging the younger generation and has already led to the dramatic collapse of student performance.

To get back on track, radical transformations are needed, and we must acknowledge that we have been largely misguided for several decades. Abolish the unique middle school and restore tracks in the second cycle (high school), make the baccalaureate the first university degree again, return to teaching the fundamentals – it is quite abnormal that students who enter university are unable to write correct French and read and understand a text longer than half a page!

Flattery and Manipulations

Flattery is a dangerous poison. Plato already pointed this out. The worst service one can render to this youth is to flatter them, which politicians rarely refrain from doing, like this presidential candidate who announces that he refuses any selection and that if there are 30,000 more candidates to enter university, 30,000 places will be created; elsewhere, he boasts that, for the first time in history, young people will teach the old whom to vote for… When we learned La Fontaine’s fables, we knew that “every flatterer lives at the expense of those who listen to him.”

This disoriented young generation, haunted by the unsettling specter of nihilism, is ready to throw itself into anything. The openly displayed “Palestinianism” with the keffiyeh and the Hamas flag is the ultimate stage of nihilism. The development of movements built on a “racial” basis contributes to this pulverization of minds. Fortunately, all these movements remain minority, but they can do a lot of harm in the face of a passive and increasingly ignorant majority. But we must ask how young people largely subjected to “deconstruction” and swayed by LGBTQ++ ideology can support Salafist or Brotherhood movements that reserve an unenviable fate for homosexuals.

All this must create a strange mush in their heads. In fact, it is not the Brotherhood doctrine that attracts them, but the place given to violence and hatred that fascinates them. At a time when all Marxist revolutionary ideologies have lost all appeal, Islamism seems to provide an attractive form to all the middle classes claiming their social ascent and wanting to take the place of those who are already there. To borrow from Peter Turchin’s analyses, there is an overproduction of elites (or so-called elites!) and the struggle for positions necessarily becomes fierce!

The Trick of History

This is not new. May 1968 was a typical example of the tricks of history. The new educated elites believed they were making the revolution (Ho, Ho Chi Minh, Che, Che, Che Guevara!!!). Some fancied themselves as “red guards” and were the vanguard of the fight against the “mandarins” and “bourgeois culture.” In doing so, they fully aligned with the positions of a part of the capitalist class, which considered classical culture vain and unnecessarily costly. The “sexual revolution” itself ultimately entered into the new views of a capitalist class that wanted to free itself definitively from a very cumbersome old world. Pier Paolo Pasolini was one of the first to clearly perceive what was at stake. He saw very well that the “antifascist” gesticulation against an archaeological fascism was nothing more than the preparation for a new fascism, the fascism of the antifascists.

It took some time for this to become obvious. The general workers’ strike of May-June 1968 had given the student movement the “proletarian” veneer it needed. Today, there is nothing like that. The working classes, the “ordinary people” dear to Christophe Guilluy, no longer march. They know that, as usual, they will be the dupes of the farce. The clean-cut young people who come to defend LFI’s positions on all television platforms cannot completely fool anyone. They do not want a social revolution, but simply this “citizen revolution” of the “new France.” The issue is a new domination; it is always about who will wield the whip.

D. C.

The editorial team recommends

Fancy reading all the articles?

Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.

Subscription

Unlock all articles straight away.

Subscribe

Newsletter

Receive the top headlines every week

Sign up
Activer les notifications OK Non