Why we cannot not call ourselves Christians…
The visit of Pope Leo XIV to France, beyond the controversies of the moment, is a good opportunity to question our relationship with Christianity. When I say "our," I mean the citizens of this secular republic that is ours, not only secular but also largely "de-Christianized," as there are many Christians who do not believe in God or are unsure if God exists. I will approach this question from the angle that seems to me today the most fundamental, that is to say, from the philosophical angle.
By Denis Collin
Published on 22 September 2026

Augustine, with his Confessions, plays a key role in the birth of the "I," in the genealogy of the self.
In 1942, the great Italian philosopher Benedetto Croce wrote a short pamphlet entitled “Why We Cannot Help but Call Ourselves Christians.” Croce had rather distant relations with God – he could have said like Voltaire, when God and I cross paths, we greet each other. One of his works, his History of Europe in the Nineteenth Century (1931), earned him harsh criticism from the Vatican, and the Holy Office placed the book on the index in 1932. The author having shown no remorse, all of his work was placed on the index in 1934…
Things to discover
So are we “Christians”? Croce says that this designation is the simple truth and that the consideration of history is sufficient to convince oneself of it. Who is this “we” that Croce speaks of? Croce himself? Italians? Europeans and their extensions on other continents? He writes to his friend, the poetess Maria Curtopassi: “… I have continued, and almost finished, these days the New Testament. […] I am deeply convinced and persuaded that modern thought and civilization are Christian, the continuation of the impulse given by Jesus and Paul.
I have written a brief note on this subject, of a historical nature, which I will publish as soon as I have the available space. For the rest, do you not feel that, in this terrible world war, what is opposed is a still Christian conception of life with another that could date back to the pre-Christian age, even pre-Hellenic and pre-Oriental, and link to this before civilization, the barbaric violence of the horde?”
For Croce, Christianity has been the greatest revolution that humanity has accomplished, “so great, so complete and profound, so fruitful in consequences, so unexpected and irresistible in its implementation, that it is not surprising that it has appeared or may appear as a miracle, a revelation from above, a direct intervention of God in human affairs.” There is no question of faith! For Croce, Christianity marks a deep, radical break.
All previous revolutions (Greece, Rome) remain limited, and the great intellectual revolutions of modern times have only been possible on the basis of this revolution introduced by Christianity. “The reason is that the Christian revolution has operated in the center of the soul, in moral consciousness, and, by giving and highlighting the interior and the proper of this consciousness, it seems to have acquired a new virtue, a new spiritual quality, of which humanity was until then devoid.”
It seems difficult to disagree with Croce on this assessment. Augustine, with his Confessions, plays a key role in the birth of the “I,” in the genealogy of the self. He is one of the best expressions of “the spirit of Christianity.” And it is indeed the enigma of the self that constitutes the common thread of European thought, heir to the Christianized Roman Empire, to which one must also link the second and third Rome (Athens and Moscow) — and avoid reducing it to the Catholic Church of the West. This search for the self can easily be found in poetry, in classical literature — the French novels of the 17th century are a good example — in painting and in sculpture. But also obviously in philosophy. Whatever the architectural beauty of mosques, they express all the submission of man to God and the human soul has no place there. The Christian invention of God made man, an invention that brings to light the truth of religion according to Feuerbach — it is man who makes God — has produced works that touch us deeply in the soul.
The revolution at the very heart of the soul that Croce speaks of is the matrix of freedom of conscience
Let us follow Croce further: “Although all past history flows in us and we are the children of all history, ancient ethics and religion have been surpassed and resolved in the Christian idea of conscience and moral inspiration, and in the new idea of God in whom we are, live and move, and who can be neither Zeus nor Yahweh, nor even (despite the adulations he has received in our days) the Germanic Wotan; and therefore, more particularly in moral life and thought, we feel directly the children of Christianity.” This is why, for Croce, all modern European thought, whether it concerns Galilean science or the philosophy of Vico, Kant, and Hegel, is the heir of Christianity.
This revolution operating in the human soul has brought to the forefront the universality of human life. Something unites us to every man, as he is a man! Not to man in general, but to the individual with whom I speak or to whom I think. To think humanity in each singular man. Love your neighbor, even your enemy! Incredible commandment, almost impossible to uphold, and yet the very core of modern civilization. Even your enemy and perhaps even first your enemy, for loving one’s friends is nothing easier!
Christianity did not invent everything. The beginnings of this conception of man can be found among the Stoic philosophers, but they ultimately accept the world as it is, since the order of the world does not depend on us, and only seek to protect themselves within this world, to build this “inner citadel” to use Pierre Hadot’s expression in his introduction to the thought of Marcus Aurelius. Christianity, on the contrary, is from the outset a new organization of the world. From the first Christian communities, those to which Paul of Tarsus addresses until the edifice of the Church, the body of Christ, it is about giving life to this revolution of consciousness, to make it effective.
It is the Church that succeeded in civilizing all the “barbarians” who had seized the Roman Empire, had dismembered it and imposed their own legislation. The baptism of Clovis is not just a popular image, one of those images that adorned our history books in primary school, it is the mark of the entry of the Franks into a new order built, however, only recently around the Church. In many ways, it is to the Church that we owe the salvation of a good part of ancient culture. In the garments of Christian theology, Greek philosophy will survive and produce a little later new fruits. This is something that should never be forgotten. Certainly, the copyist monks sometimes took liberties with the texts they had before them and they did not always use the text establishment methods that would have been appropriate.
However, one must not forget that what has survived from ancient culture on the Arab-Muslim side is also due to Christians who translated the Greek of Plato and Aristotle into Syriac and then into Arabic. In other words, what is sometimes presented to us as the great contribution of Islam is of Christian origin! Plato in Avicenna, Aristotle in Averroes: the intermediate link is Christian.
The revolution at the very heart of the soul that Croce speaks of is the matrix of freedom of conscience. I know in advance the objections: and the Inquisition? And the “witch hunts”? And Bruno? And Galileo? All these cases must, however, be considered as reactions of the body of the Church to the undesirable effects of Christianity. There are indeed, at the heart of Christianity, two deeply disturbing ideas: one is not born a Christian, but one becomes one, one could say to paraphrase a famous motto, and what is truly sacred is man.
It is no coincidence that it is Christian nations that first articulated the natural rights of man
These two ideas regularly put the Church as a power apparatus in a bind. One is not born a Christian, indeed, one must be baptized, but as one baptizes grandchildren to prevent them from wandering eternally in limbo, this baptism must be confirmed when the child enters adolescence and thus fully into the community of Christians. One must say “yes” in one’s own voice to become a Christian! A second example is that of marriage. In all societies, including those dominated by Christianity, marriages are family affairs and are more or less arranged. However, Christian societies were the first to begin to emerge from this millennial servitude: marriage being a sacrament, the married couple must consent, as they consented during their solemn communion, but here they must consent to this marriage — and it is indeed this consent that makes it indissoluble.
If, for example, the bride does not consent, then the Church must protect her. Marian worship will also play a significant role in the evolution of Christian mentalities, and female Christian communities will become true hotbeds of subversion of the patriarchal order — think, for example, of the beguinages. Paul and his maxims reinforcing the inferiority of women are often cited, but it is the same Paul who asserts that, henceforth, with the proclamation of the good news, there is neither man nor woman, as there is neither master nor slave, nor Jew nor Gentile…
It is no coincidence that it is Christian nations that first articulated the natural rights of man. According to Hegel, Christianity first posited that man as such is free, whereas ancient despotisms proclaimed that only one man is free (the tyrant) and that ancient republics like those in Greece asserted that only a few are free. Man is free, but how can he be, since he is a creature of God? This is exactly what the incarnation says: Jesus is God made man, he is both the son of God and the son of man, and one must conclude that God and man are the same thing and that, therefore, it is man who is sacred in Christianity. In Christianity, one does not submit to the power of God, one assumes one’s freedom by conducting oneself according to the precepts laid down by Christ.
It is therefore not necessary to believe in a personal and transcendent God (a logically very strange thing) to call oneself a Christian. The theological framework of Christianity can easily be set aside. One can therefore be a Christian and “atheist” (an atheist who thinks that man is a God for man) and thus rediscover the profound meaning of Ernst Bloch’s great book, Atheism in Christianity.
D. C.
Bibliography : Croce, B., Why Can’t We Not Call Ourselves “Christians”?, Rivages, Poche, 2026
Fancy reading all the articles?
Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.