September 11, 2001: what the West has not learned
Published on 11 September 2026

Twenty-five years later, we commemorate. We reflect. We repeat "never forget." But we have largely forgotten to draw conclusions.
On September 11, 2026, it remains primarily a ritual. Reading of names at Ground Zero. Minutes of silence. Two beams of light in the Manhattan sky. The towers are no longer there. Al-Qaeda is no longer there either, at least not as it was in 2001. Politically, the Western assessment is harsher.
Twenty-five years later, we commemorate. We reflect. We repeat “never forget.” But we have largely forgotten to draw conclusions. September 11 did not only kill 2,977 people. It opened a test of truth for the West: did it still know how to name its enemy, defend its borders, and uphold its civilization without apologizing for existing?
No comparable attack has been committed on American soil. Cockpits have been reinforced, airports transformed, intelligence interconnected. Bin Laden was killed in 2011. NATO’s Article 5 has been invoked only once in the history of the Alliance, and it was to defend the United States. Tactically, the “war on terror” has achieved its primary objective: to prevent a second September 11.
Before 2001, hijacking a commercial airplane still seemed, to some, like a movie scenario. Afterward, the system held. The United States has not experienced an attack of that magnitude since. Al-Qaeda has been decapitated, hunted down, fragmented. ISIS has been territorially crushed. To say that “nothing has changed” is false.
Afghanistan returned to the Taliban in August 2021, almost twenty years to the day after the intervention. Iraq, invaded in 2003 in the name of non-existent weapons of mass destruction, opened a field of ruins from which ISIS emerged. The Middle East has not been democratized. It has been fragmented. Iran has taken advantage of the void. Turkey has played its game. Russia and China watched America get bogged down, then withdraw.
The United States has emerged more fatigued, more divided, less self-assured. “Endless wars” have become an electoral argument. Part of American public opinion has concluded that it should no longer “be the world’s policeman.” Another has concluded that it should no longer trust the experts. Both are right on one point: the promise of a clear and moral victory has not been kept.
Europe, for its part, has often chosen commentary over engagement. It criticized Washington, then suffered Madrid in 2004, London in 2005, Toulouse, Paris, the Bataclan, Nice, Brussels, Strasbourg, Arras.
It has multiplied tributes to the victims while shying away from the diagnosis. We talked about “isolated youths,” “social fractures,” and “American foreign policy.” We talked less about the ideology that connected these crimes.
What the West did not want to see
September 11 was not just an attack. It was an ideological war waged in the name of a political Islam that refuses to distinguish between faith, law, and sovereignty. The nineteen men of Al-Qaeda were not illiterate hungry individuals. Several had lived in the West, studied, traveled. They did not attack “capitalism” in a vague sense. They attacked America as the head of the West, Israel as an ally, and the “impious” Muslim world that accommodated this order.
Twenty-five years later, part of the chancelleries, universities, and newsrooms continues to treat the phenomenon as a collateral effect of poverty, colonization, or Israeli policy. This is an intellectual failure. It has a practical consequence: we finance “deradicalization” measures while refusing to say what radicalizes. We monitor individuals while denying the corpus that arms them. As long as we refuse to name this conviction, we treat the symptom and leave the source intact.
October 7, 2023, brutally reminded us that the problem was not closed in 2001. The massacre by Hamas, the processions in European capitals, the normalization of anti-Semitism under the guise of the “Palestinian cause” showed that part of the West still did not understand the nature of the enemy. We repeated the same phrases. The same precautions. The same blind spots.
What we have accepted at home
Mass surveillance, the Patriot Act, profiling, cameras, S files, repeated anti-terrorism laws—the state has armed itself. At the same time, a persistent naivety has survived regarding immigration, communitarianism, and radicalization in European suburbs. We have increased police powers while weakening the political clarity that makes a society defensible.
We wanted to be ruthless in Kabul and indifferent in Saint-Denis. We sent soldiers to rebuild Afghan schools while, at home, we hesitated to expel preachers, to close Salafist mosques, to say that a nation is not an airport terminal. Technical security has progressed. Cultural sovereignty has receded.
The paradox is cruel. The West has accepted to be searched in airports. It has been less willing to ask who it allows in, under what rules, and in the name of what historical continuity. September 11 should have produced a doctrine, an assimilation, real secularism, an end to denial. It produced scanners and conferences.
The true political legacy
September 11 revealed three things.
First, military power is not enough. You can destroy a regime and lose a society. You can kill a leader and let an ideology live on.
Second, the enemy is not a classic state. It is a network, a doctrine, a capacity to recruit from diasporas, prisons, social networks. Treating it as a simple matter of domestic police or regional diplomacy is to misjudge the scale.
Third, the elites who promised a clear victory have lost some of their credibility. From this distrust have emerged American withdrawal, polarization, and a Europe more anxious than assured. We have fewer certainties than in September 2001. We do not necessarily have more courage.
A civilization that no longer dares to say what it is, nor what it refuses, invites those who do know very well. September 11, 2001, did not only bring down two towers. It tested whether the West was still capable of defending itself without renouncing itself.
Defending oneself is not just about lining up drones and exceptional laws. It is about holding a narrative: we have a history, a right, a freedom of conscience, gender equality, popular sovereignty. These principles are non-negotiable in the name of “living together.” They are the condition for living together.
Twenty-five years later, the answer is still not clear-cut. The ceremonies continue. The lessons, however, remain pending.
Fancy reading all the articles?
Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.