No, a looter is not a revolutionary!
We will not talk here about the demonstrations; our country has known several and will know more. Expressing discontent and making social and political demands are a legitimate and constitutional right in republican France. No, here we will discuss the behaviors of vandals who loot, assault, violently attack, and destroy.
By Jean-Baptiste Chikhi-Budjeia
Published on 20 October 2026

The media did not invent the collapse of the bell tower of the town hall of Limoges.
“False patriots want to push everything to the extreme, to turn excessive measures to the benefit of counter-revolution.” Robespierre at the Jacobin Club, 8 Frimaire Year II (November 28, 1793).
Thus, in the thinking of the men of the 18th century, those who led the French Revolution, who fought for freedom and public education for all, engaging in excesses, worse, in looting and destruction of public property, would have been accused of being agents of the Counter-Revolution.
We will obviously emphasize that many processions of demonstrators took place peacefully and warmly on October 17, with citizens legitimately carrying just social demands, particularly against the high cost of living. But those who (unjustly) accuse the media of not mentioning this are also those who refuse to see this other reality, that of savagery, that of looting, that of assaults, all committed by savages, and far from being a minority.
The media did not invent the collapse of the burning bell tower of the town hall of Limoges, they did not invent the cowardly assault on a shopkeeper in Nice, nor did they invent the death threats, nor so many other terrible realities experienced firsthand by many of our compatriots. It must be said with severity and even triviality, leftism, of which Lenin himself wrote that it was the infantile disorder of communism, leftism, steeped in misery, condescension, primary anti-capitalism, and denial, is a software that has been outdated from the start and precisely feeds what it claims to combat.
We will not talk here about the demonstrations; our country has known several and will know more. Expressing discontent and making social and political demands are a legitimate and constitutional right in republican France. No, here we will discuss the behaviors of vandals who loot, assault, violently attack, and destroy.
We have seen and heard here and there that the municipality of Marseille would be a new Bastille to be taken, that the delinquents and looters, who in 1789 would have been called “bandits,” would be revolutionaries. But what a farce! Where are the foreign armies descending upon the people whose dead, not the injured, the dead, number in the dozens, or more? We can be among those who regularly target precisely the shortcomings of the current power in terms of diplomatic deficiencies, educational failures, betrayals of secularism, cowardice, and regal incompetence, etc. For our part, we do this in light of history and by putting solutions on the table (which one is entitled not to share), but let us remember:
1) that we must distinguish between a despotism (what the Revolution faced) and an aristocracy or an oligarchy (what we live in);
2) that unlike what the Revolution faced, we are not surrounded by foreign armies bombing our cities, and that the internal enemies, actors of the counter-revolution, do not assassinate patriots and do not deliver our cities to the enemy.
3) that even the most radical revolutionaries in the popular movement, before any action of force and the use of violence, targeted against the enemies of the homeland, engaged in legalistic approaches (by the way, let us recall the famous phrase of Danton, “Let us be terrible to spare the people from being so”),
4) that the revolutionary leaders did everything to contain popular revolutionary violence, even decreeing in 1793, by the Convention, an assembly in which a certain Robespierre sat, measures against vandalism in order to also protect the heritage from the Ancien Régime. Thus, for example, on 3 Brumaire Year II (October 24, 1793), the decree from the very leftist Gilbert Romme (who notably worked on the development of the republican calendar) prohibited damaging monuments even under the pretext of making feudal or royal symbols disappear! Moreover, the revolutionaries did not throw Marianne to the ground; they created her, they elevated her.
Who can dare to say that behind the looting of the means of production, of the tools of work, the looting of small and large businesses, looting that leaves employees, small business owners, and proletarians in the lurch, there is some social demand?! And we must here commend the strong statement from PS-Place publique deputy François Kalfon, who condemned, on October 18, without the slightest ambiguity, the looters and their looting, and called for an extremely firm response. This is far too rare on the left not to be highlighted.
The leftist is almost by definition brainless, and by their relativization and invocation of the Revolution to justify the destruction of public property, they serve the counter-revolutionary discourse that denounces it. But here it is, historical reality offers them contradiction. In Aix-en-Provence, the popular society of Antipolitics, at the far left of the political spectrum, deliberated, for example, on 3 Messidor Year II (June 21, 1794), thus at the heart of what some still call “the Terror”: “It is announced to the society that young children are outraging several citizens, that they are burning rockets that can cause damage. It is decided to ask the municipality to make a proclamation by which it will hold parents responsible for their children’s faults, and furthermore to defend [= prohibit] any citizen from selling serpentaux and finally that anyone caught damaging the benches of the Cour [today Mirabeau] will be condemned to pay for them[1].”
Who can dare to assert that behind the ransacking and arson of a town hall, which during the French Revolution was called “the Common House,” there is a revolutionary act to propose better days? Who can still turn a blind eye to the criminal acts committed by scum who beat, assault, and molest, all while spewing their hatred of France, sometimes waving Palestinian or Algerian flags, their faces masked behind keffiyehs, scarves, or surgical masks. No, we will not call you “Citizens”; you are bandits, delinquents, thieves, and you do not take from the rich to give to the poor. If we let ourselves go, we could tell you that you are nothing but filth. And there are worse than you; there are those who support you, who come to your aid on TV sets and in radio studios. It is Robespierre, again, who opposes you, while he confirmed on December 5, 1793, to the face of the ultras, that he was not one of them: “Republicans want neither the moderation that kills the Republic nor the exaggeration that loses it.”
We must be outraged, oppose our virulent disapproval against all the artisans of chaos. Moreover, since we have recognized the guilt of those who indulge in the most unbridled violence, let us try to distinguish the responsible parties.
1) Emmanuel Macron. The President of the Republic, who in 2022 indulged in the luxury of depriving us of an electoral campaign, and who, having become a minority, has never drawn the Gaullist lessons from his disavowal by the people, has refused to resign. In doing so, he has rendered the country ungovernable, the state powerless, he has contributed to fracturing the nation, and, having made a spectacular takeover of the center, has managed to make believe that his powerlessness, his ambivalences, and his permanent ambiguity were centrism. This “en même temps” deleterious, which has nothing to do with centrism, which is merely a careerist, opportunistic approach to the life of the City, leads him to send contradictory messages to the different parties involved, can only give birth to disorder, to chaos. Why does the President of the Republic not act? Out of cowardice, out of fear, or in the hope of being able to maintain power in this way?
2) The cardboard revolutionaries. These are all those who, on the left and its extremes, have turned their backs on the Enlightenment, have betrayed the legacy of the French Revolution, and have violated the struggles and historical victories of republican France. They fanaticize the youth, cover up crimes and destruction, even by relativizing them. It is not only elected officials or party leaders, but also grassroots militants, engaging on social networks in comments that assert, among other things, that the products sold in looted and destroyed stores are useless and polluting. Do not see malice in this; it is certainly not to assert that it is legitimate to destroy these stores, for the most extremist of fanatics, it would also be about saving the planet.
So Marat, even more effervescent than Robespierre, also warns against the ultra-revolutionaries in his journal, nine days before being assassinated:
“The cruelest scourge we have to combat to make freedom triumph is not the aristocrats, the royalists, the counter-revolutionaries, but the false patriots exalted who claim their mask of civism to mislead good citizens and throw them into violent, reckless, and disastrous actions.
These intriguers do not content themselves with being the factotums of their respective sections; they agitate from morning till night to infiltrate all popular societies, influence them, and finally become their great makers[2].”
Let us return to 2026. The new fact, at least it has terribly intensified in recent weeks, lies in the shift of violence. Once, the scum spoiled the lives of honest people in the suburbs; today, they invade the city centers of the bourgeois who, precisely, denied what workers in popular neighborhoods suffered daily. Now that the affluent left-wing voter sees their comfort violated, will they finally open their eyes or take refuge, as can be read here and there or heard among the listeners of this or that radio, in paranoid conspiracy theories: Macron is deliberately letting it happen. Let us pass over the arguments given, if one can even speak of arguments…
The weakness of a paralyzed power will obviously have struck everyone’s eyes, a power that did not hesitate to send armored police against the yellow vests, those workers who asked to live with dignity from the fruits of their labor. In the face of scum, one weighs… But the current power should beware of weighing excessively, for then the exhausted citizen, the frightened merchant, the exasperated worker, might well take up the weapon that the State does not use. If the latter does not use force and does not deliver justice, beware, the citizen might decide to do it in its place and the spiral would then be terrible…
[1] Departmental archives of Bouches-du-Rhône, L 2031: minutes of deliberations of 3 Messidor Year II (June 21, 1794), pp. 85-86 / 266-267.
[2] Jean-Paul Marat, Publicist of the French Republic, no. 233, July 4, 1793.
The editorial team recommends
Fancy reading all the articles?
Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.