Presidential 2027: Mélenchon eco-friendly? (1069 proposals, not one more, continuation)
What LFI proposes is nothing more than a "green capitalism," directed in a Soviet manner – Mélenchon is addressing the bosses to show them the interest of collaboration between French hierarchs and the Mélenchonized state, a political capitalism like that found in China, Russia, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, and a few other charming countries.
By Denis Collin
Published on 14 November 2026

Five years ago already...
I previously emphasized how absurd Mélenchon’s program is since it simultaneously asserts its desire to remain in the EU and in the euro while proposing moratoriums and acts of disobedience to fundamental principles of the EU – Mélenchon, on this point, resembles Tsipras like two drops of water, and we know where that leads. Today, I would like to talk about what LFI presents as its strongest point: a large-scale ecological program.
The key point is the “green rule”: “To enshrine in the Constitution the principle of the ‘green rule’, according to which we do not take more from nature than it is able to regenerate.” This rule seems full of common sense: good management, like that of a ‘father of the family’, consists of not spending more than one earns. But if we study its practical meaning, then this rule is rather vague and even quite hollow. In absolute terms, we take nothing from nature without returning to it in another form what we have taken. Every student who has attended high school knows what a balance equation is: at the end of a chemistry experiment, one must find the same total mass of product as at the beginning… but transformed, and that’s where the troubles begin.
Iron first results from the extraction of iron ore, and if we want to develop rail transport, we will need to build new tracks and therefore manufacture rails. How do we return this iron to nature? We recycle, but recycling is not free: it consumes energy. Regarding “rare earths”, recycling is often practically impossible because they are used in very small quantities in all electronic devices. Estimates on copper consumption, which should accelerate with the electrification of transport, are very pessimistic, not because the Earth lacks copper, but because it is becoming increasingly difficult to extract: we have gone from 8% copper per unit of ore to less than 1%. Aurore Stephant has precisely dismantled the illusions about the “green” transition, electric cars, and other eco-gadgets. She emphasizes the major role that large infrastructures play in this overconsumption of ore.
If we wanted to give meaning to the “green rule”, we would need to follow the indications given, each in their field, by people who know what they are talking about, such as Jean-Marc Jancovici and the “Shift Project”, Philippe Bihouix and his proposals in favor of Low Techs, or Aurore Stéphant on the necessary frugality in mineral consumption, and they all converge towards a few precise proposals that can be summarized as follows: we need to divide our energy and material consumption by 4. We must stop deluding ourselves with the catch-all expressions that pepper the LFI document: “launch a major plan for ecologically and socially useful investments”, “Plan for France’s catch-up in terms of industrial robotization to match Germany, which is 400 robots for 10,000 employees”, “Develop robotics sectors in health, the sea, and space”, because all this only reinforces our dependence on massive infrastructures and thus on energy and mineral consumption. We need not more robots, but fewer robots. More generally, we need to break with the ideology of growth, even “green” growth.
But, according to its ideology with a strong Soviet flavor, LFI proposes “big plans”. Thus, to combat climate change, “engage in a global plan to renovate our infrastructures to adapt to climate change”, “a pollution cleanup plan for the Mediterranean”, “renovate all water and sanitation networks to limit leaks and guarantee the human right to water and sanitation”, “invest in energy efficiency and sobriety, as well as in innovative energy projects like renewable marine energies”, etc. Since LFI is part of the sect of electric car fanatics, they propose a “big plan” to develop the economical electric car. Etc. But all these big plans multiply consumption, render tools or infrastructures that could still function for a long time obsolete, and create new structures, new administrations, and all kinds of committees.
One of the flagship measures is the exit from nuclear and fossil energies. But the renewables are hydroelectric (do they propose new dams), wind, and solar (intermittent and polluting in manufacturing and dismantling) and wood. If we heat massively with wood, there will soon be no more forests! Hydroelectricity is not expandable. As for the sun and wind, we would need to be able to store energy, and thus, as the program announces, a big storage plan is necessary. Not once is the environmental impact of wind turbines or solar panel fields questioned. They surely have a “big plan”…
We want to promote a rational approach to these techniques: neither techno-enthusiastic nor technophobic
And here is, so to speak, the cherry on the cake: “Against GHG emissions and animal mistreatment, reduce our average consumption of animal proteins (meat, fish, dairy products, eggs) by 50%.” In other words, they are not even proposing a vegetarian diet, but a pure vegan diet that the Khmer Rouge of LFI are offering us. It is quite amusing coming from the defenders of “Master Chicken”. We are told that young people place Mélenchon at the top of their voting intentions. Yet they are serious consumers of animal proteins (big mac, kebab, etc.).
But the essential point is elsewhere: here is a political program that extends to dietary habits! This is unprecedented. It even includes education on nutrition, to shape young minds to reject meat in all its forms. Furthermore, if we replace animal proteins with plant proteins, it is a serious boost to the cereal agribusiness, and in corollary, the last nail in the coffin of French peasantry. The proposals to create 500,000 jobs in agriculture are therefore smoke and mirrors if we must start by liquidating half of the cows, sheep, poultry, and pigs (one wonders why there is not a big plan for the eradication of pigs, these animals being, in the eyes of LFI, fascist and Islamophobic animals).
I do not know what the ideal diet is; there are many contradictory opinions on the subject, but this proposal is revealing of the philosophy of these maniacs of big plans: dictating what one should eat and what one should think.
It is noteworthy that the project makes no mention of artificial intelligence in the ecology chapter. However, the fabulous energy consumption of these toys with potentially destructive consequences could have been questioned. But no, there is a good AI, for Mélenchon and his friends, a progressive AI: “If artificial intelligence (AI) poses problems today, it is primarily because it is entirely controlled by North American giants, closely linked to the U.S. government.
The AI systems, which they flood the planet with, are ecologically irresponsible and are based on the myth of creating a “universal genius”. We want to promote a rational approach to these techniques: neither techno-enthusiastic nor technophobic. We need to take control: develop AI ourselves when it serves human progress objectives and limit it otherwise.” “Develop AI ourselves”: yet another expression devoid of meaning. Whether French or American, AI consumes fabulous amounts of electricity and gives those who develop it powers of surveillance, elimination of employees, and radical transformation of culture and thought itself.
In conclusion, what LFI proposes is nothing more than a “green capitalism,” directed in a Soviet manner – Mélenchon is addressing the bosses to show them the interest of collaboration between French hierarchs and the Mélenchonized state, a political capitalism like that found in China, Russia, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, and a few other charming countries. But, we will be told, it is “democratic”… just like the former “people’s” democracies were.
The editorial team recommends
Fancy reading all the articles?
Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.