Violence of October 17: an inquiry commission already weakened by its composition, Marine Le Pen denounces a “charade”
The inquiry commission tasked with examining the violence surrounding the protests of October 17 and 18 appointed three rapporteurs (Horizons-PS-Ecologist) on Tuesday, but none from the RN, with Marine Le Pen denouncing a "masquerade" and promising a boycott from her group.
Published on 22 October 2026

Marine Le Pen, presidential candidate, deemed the commission "discredited before it even began its work. We will not participate in this masquerade."
Launched to shed light on the violence of October 17, the inquiry commission of the National Assembly is immediately distinguished by a contested political balance. Presided over by Vincent Caure (Together for the Republic), it is co-reported by Agnès Firmin Le Bodo (Horizons), Roger Vicot (Socialists), and Pouria Amirshahi (Ecologist and Social).
Things to discover
No elected representatives from the Republicans, UDR, or the National Rally hold positions of responsibility, while the president of the Law Commission had mentioned, a few hours earlier, a distribution among the three major blocs of the assembly.
The body follows the riots of Saturday, October 17, 2026. Amid mobilizations in several cities, clashes, looting, and damage of an unusual scale led Yaël Braun-Pivet to propose an inquiry commission. The stated goal is to establish the facts, analyze the operational methods of violent groups, and examine any dysfunctions in maintaining order. The conference of presidents validated the approach on October 20, and the Law Commission immediately equipped itself with investigative powers.
The appointment of the rapporteurs on October 21, however, did not follow the announced scheme. Vincent Caure had argued for three co-rapporteurs representing the left, the central bloc, and the RN-UDR alliance. The secret ballot, organized in three rounds, produced a different result. Thomas Portes (La France insoumise) withdrew in the last round, stating he did not want “a rapporteur from the National Rally.” This gesture favored Pouria Amirshahi against RN candidate Michaël Taverne, who received 23 votes against 28 according to parliamentary sources. The final trio thus excludes the RN-UDR bloc.
The selected profiles raise questions; Roger Vicot has put forward a bill aimed at restricting the conditions for the use of weapons by law enforcement in cases of non-compliance and voted against the presumption of legitimate defense.
Pouria Amirshahi has been very critical of the doctrine of maintaining order. Agnès Firmin Le Bodo, former Minister of Health, completes the group.
A “masquerade” for the RN
The contrast with the Senate is striking. On the same day, the Law Commission of the Upper Assembly appointed the Republican senator from Manche, David Margueritte, as co-rapporteur of an information mission on the events of October 17 and 18, alongside Olivier Bitz, Horizon.
The mission is presented as transpartisan. David Margueritte is also co-rapporteur of the so-called “rioters-pay” bill.
In the Assembly, Marine Le Pen reacted immediately. “Contrary to the promise made by the group presidents in the conference of presidents, the left maneuvered to prevent the RN from having, in the inquiry commission on October 17, a rapporteur out of the 3 planned. This commission thus becomes a leftist inner circle whose goal will again be to blame the police (…) this commission is discredited before it even begins its work. We will not participate in this masquerade,” she declared.
“The National Rally, the leading political force in the country, is deprived of the rapporteur position that was supposed to go to Michaël Taverne. Thus, the party that the French consider the most credible to address the country’s security issues is sidelined,” the party with the flame further stated in a press release.
Contrary to the promise made by the group presidents in the conference of presidents, the left maneuvered to prevent the RN from having, in the inquiry commission on October 17, a rapporteur out of the 3 planned. This commission thus becomes a leftist inner circle whose goal will again be to blame the police. This commission is discredited before it even begins its work. We will not participate in this masquerade.
— Marine Le Pen (@MLP_officiel) October 21, 2026
This boycott has concrete consequences. RN deputies will not participate in either the hearings or the investigations. However, the rapporteurs hold key powers: drafting the final report, organizing sworn hearings, and having priority access to documents. Without the main opposition group in these positions, the work will proceed without internal checks.
The report, drafted by a trio composed of one Horizons elected official and two left-wing elected officials, may be disqualified a priori by the RN as biased. The boycott does not prevent the commission from functioning, but it reduces its ability to claim broad legitimacy and opens the door to systematic contestation of its conclusions.
The question remains: can a commission tasked with examining urban violence claim broad legitimacy when one of the three main blocs of the Assembly is absent from its key positions and chooses to boycott the work, while the Senate has opted for a more open configuration?
The editorial team recommends
- From student protest to civil war: a play in four acts and an epilogue
- Violence of October 17: Gérald Darmanin announces 149 arrests, the penal response must be “extremely firm”
- The “troublemakers” against the social movement
Fancy reading all the articles?
Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.