Paty, Bernard: two teachers murdered, a republic challenged
There are deaths that should prevent a nation from sleeping peacefully. Deaths that force us to confront what we have become, what we have allowed to settle in, what we have sometimes preferred not to see.
Published on 13 October 2026

Samuel Paty taught freedom of expression. Dominique Bernard taught literature.
Samuel Paty was assassinated on October 16, 2020. Dominique Bernard was killed on October 13, 2023. Two teachers. Two men who chose to impart knowledge, to open minds, to keep alive that old ambition of the republican school ― to teach children to think for themselves. They were struck by Islamist terrorism, at the heart of what should be the sanctuary of intellectual freedom.
I refuse to let us turn their memory into a ritual. A few speeches, some wreaths, moments of silence, then back to our usual precautions. The silence we must observe in front of their coffins has nothing to do with the silence that fanatics wanted to impose in their classrooms. A teacher should be able to teach without fearing for their life. This statement should be an absolute given. The fact that it has become a demand says something terrible about the state of our country.
Things to discover
Samuel Paty taught freedom of expression. Dominique Bernard taught literature. Both embodied that transmission which allows the individual to free themselves from assignments, dogmas, and imposed truths. They reminded us, through their very profession, that intelligence is not received on one’s knees and that knowledge does not have to ask for permission from beliefs. This is precisely what Islamism cannot tolerate.
We must name things here without trembling, but without ever confusing people and ideas. But this demand for justice should not lead us to turn a blind eye to a political project that seeks to submit society, laws, and freedoms to a religious norm. Islamism is not a mere spiritual sensitivity. It is an ambition for power. When it targets a teacher for public outrage, when it threatens freedom of conscience, when it claims to dictate what can be shown, said, or taught, it goes to war against the Republic. And the Republic should not negotiate its freedom.
I am a universalist. I believe that we belong first to a common humanity, before being confined to communities, origins, or prescribed identities. I believe that school should teach every child that they can become something other than what their birth, environment, or surroundings had planned for them. I believe that secularism protects this possibility. It does not ask anyone to renounce their spiritual intimacy. It guarantees that no dogma can impose itself on all. This is what we defend when we defend the republican school. And this is why the assassinations of Paty and Bernard are not mere individual tragedies. They touch on the contract that allows us to live together. They raise a question we can no longer evade: what is our freedom worth if those who transmit it are abandoned in the face of those who want to destroy it?
We have long confused tolerance with capitulation, understanding with excuse, caution with renunciation. We have sometimes treated as an ordinary controversy what was intimidation, ideological pressure, or threat. And we have allowed teachers to wonder if they could still teach certain truths, address certain texts, show certain caricatures, without jeopardizing their safety.
I do not ask teachers to be heroes. I ask them to be able to be teachers. It is the responsibility of the State, institutions, and society to guarantee them this freedom. It is up to us to ensure that no teacher is forced to choose between their professional conscience and their survival. The response cannot be solely security-based, even if protecting threatened individuals and being firm against criminals is essential. It must also be intellectual, educational, and political.
We must teach freedom of conscience, defend the right to criticize all ideas, combat intimidation, and give teachers the unambiguous support they need. We must also refuse to let fear become a method of governing minds. Because if we give up transmitting what disturbs fanatics, we are already ceding a part of our territory to them. An invisible but essential territory: that of free thought. I think of these two men, their families, their colleagues, all those who continue to enter a classroom every morning with the immense responsibility of imparting knowledge. I think of their possible solitude, of that anxiety that no one should have to bear while practicing a profession dedicated to emancipation.
I refuse to let their memory be confiscated by ceremonies or partisan speeches. Paty and Bernard belong to the national consciousness. Their struggle transcends political affiliations. It concerns all those who want France to remain a Republic where one can believe or not believe, contest, caricature, read, debate, and think without fearing the violence of fanatics. We will not do them justice by merely mourning. We will do them justice by continuing what they did: transmitting, enlightening, emancipating.
A Republic that leaves its teachers alone in the face of fanaticism ultimately abandons its children to obscurantism. Samuel Paty. Dominique Bernard. Two names. Two lives taken. One same demand remains, that freedom never lowers its eyes before those who want to impose silence upon it.
Fancy reading all the articles?
Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.