When there is death, there is no “but”

If upon returning from work, a trip, or a meal, you found your family - children, spouse, parents - massacred for some, tortured and massacred for others, raped for the women, taken alive for a few others - what would your reaction have been to this discovery?

By Mahyar Monshipour Kermani

Published on 7 October 2026

When there is death, there is no “but”

Already three years, or 1,096 days, echoing the 1,219 corpses from October 7.

October 6. An afternoon like any other, Saher Nidal Latfi returns home. It’s a Friday, a day of collective prayer, that of “Joumah”. He comes back from the “Hassan Al Banna” mosque, which he likes to attend, although it is farther from his home, but more “authentic” than the others:

Just named after the one who wanted to show the right path again, the right way.

He will pray again the next day, around five thirty, for the morning prayer, the salât “al fajr”, which will actually be a Salât “al-Khawf”, the one before the battle. On his motorcycle, he stops, accompanied by his companions, performs his ablutions with sand, and prostrates towards the East. A few genuflections and he is finally ready for Jihad, the struggle for Allah.

But does he even know that it was simply one of the many (360) idols housed in the Kaaba, and more specifically that of the tribe of his future “Messenger”, that of the Qurayshi.

“Abdallah” (Servant of Allah)

He commits to the path he has known since birth. Like what happened in the epilogue of the battle of “The Trench” in 627, when all the pubescent men (400 to 700) of the Jewish Tribe of Banu Qurayza were executed. They were executed after their surrender. They were executed because it had to happen.

He was going to do the same, the path already having been traced.

Noa, Noa Argamani is excited. She finishes her workday. She will celebrate her twenty-sixth birthday in six days. But for now, it’s dancing all night that drives her.

“Don’t kill me! No, no, no!”

That’s what she screamed. A scream immortalized by a handheld or mobile camera. You know the rest.

Saher Nidal Latfi, just like during the raids of the seventh century in the Ḥiǧāz, had hopped on his motorcycle after the salât. He was convinced he was on the true path, the right path.

245 days of captivity

Noa Argamani will be released on June 8, 2024, during a military operation by Tsahal in Gaza, after 245 days of captivity.

15,000 days of a vile life

Saher Nidal Latfi Sakr, on the other hand, will be killed on September 26, 2026, during an airstrike carried out by a drone in the Nuseirat area, in the center of the Gaza Strip.

Is he now with the houris of paradise, “whom before him (them) no man or jinn has deflowered,” being served by the ghalmans, “eternally young boys, with cups, jugs, and a glass of spring water,” “as if they were pearls jealously guarded”? Or is he now a host to vermin, eaten and digested by it. Eaten and digested by other vermin.

Cannibalism

This slice of life, this story, is identical for all those murdered, kidnapped, abused, raped, because they are Jewish or Israeli.

“Right to resist against foreign occupation,” Rima Hassan

By qualifying the action of Hamas in this way, the elected representative of the rebellious has thrown acid on the memory of all true resistors, such as Lucie Aubrac, Jean Moulin, Missak Manouchian. He has splashed their graves, just like the sister of a rejected suitor would, throwing acid in the face of the one who refused the marriage proposal.

Already three years, or 1,096 days, echoing the 1,219 corpses from October 7. Already three years and about 70,000 corpses in Gaza.

Anyone who claims to be indifferent to the two figures would lack humanity; anyone who justifies it with a “but” would see me remind them of the “buts” for Charlie-Hebdo. When there is death, there is no “but.”

“But,” to conclude, I would say But:

What would we have done?

What would you have done?

What would I have done?

If upon returning from work, a trip, or a meal, you found your family – children, partner, parents – massacred for some, tortured and massacred for others, raped for the women, taken alive for a few others – what would your reaction have been to this discovery, knowing the perpetrators, having the evidence, and remaining without interlocutors to prevent any repetition, any reiteration.

Perhaps you would resolve to make a harsh, irrevocable decision that is often misunderstood.

Just in case, I hope to have the courage to do the same.

Just in case, I hope to have the courage.

M. M. K.

Fancy reading all the articles?

Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.

Subscription

Unlock all articles straight away.

Subscribe

Newsletter

Receive the top headlines every week

Sign up
Activer les notifications OK Non