October 7, 2023: the cowardice of the mind
She watches, without the slightest disturbance on her face, men in fatigues who, on Saturday, October 7, land in a hang glider at a music festival. She is at most twenty years old. She watches this as one watches a music video. The men in fatigues, on her screen, are about to kill people who were dancing an hour earlier.
By Caroline Yadan (*)
Published on 7 October 2026

The men in fatigues, on her screen, are about to kill people who were dancing an hour earlier.
She is sitting in the third seat from the door, and she is looking at her phone. The banality of the scene. Everyone looks at their phone in the Paris metro; it’s the posture of the century, the modern prayer, head down and agile thumb. Except that what she is watching, without the slightest disturbance on her face, are men in fatigues who, on Saturday, October 7, land in a hang glider at a music festival. She is at most twenty years old. She watches this as one watches a music video. The men in fatigues, on her screen, are about to kill people who were dancing an hour earlier. She knows it. It’s not ignorance. It’s worse. It’s consumption.
She also watches Jewish artists, writers, and journalists being boycotted, insulted, or violently attacked in the name of Good, human rights, or progressivism. She adheres, without even questioning it, to these exclusions.
She watches her favorite influencer, the one who sees no problem in following the instructions of an elected official being prosecuted for glorifying terrorism and inciting hatred. It doesn’t matter the lynching of a Jewish woman, the anti-Semitic insults, the contribution to a campaign of cyber harassment. What matters are the fun vlogs from August, the followers, a show at the Zenith, and the euros piling up.
Here lies the real issue, and it is not a geopolitical issue. It is this unprecedented ability that our time has acquired to transform a massacre into watchable content, a boycott of Jews into an acceptable political position, and banning into a sign of belonging to a youth that believes itself to be clear-sighted while it merely swallows, without chewing, the narrative that others have cooked up for it.
This narrative is lived as a virtue that digests reality by accepting the worst. A baby that has been strangled with bare hands becomes an anecdote that it would be inappropriate to isolate from the broader context of oppression. The explanatory grid precedes the crime and absorbs it, without even having the feeling of lying.
The inversion of the burden of proof serves as an effective tool for this mechanism, just like the words “Zionist” or “fascist” brandished as a form of excommunication. It is enough for them to be pronounced for any opposing word to become suspect, for the interlocutor to become a target to be hunted down, deprogrammed, prevented from speaking. The words don’t even need to be true, only shouted loud enough. We have invented the tribunal of disqualification, that of minds lacking arguments, which transforms disagreement into moral suspicion and the opponent into a suspect to avoid debating the substance.
We cannot yield to this mechanism driven by this new populist left, violent, Islamized, and anti-Semitic.
The left, born of the Enlightenment, today invites into its amphitheaters men who, in power, would silence it first, along with its women, its homosexuals, its free thinkers according to a logic that knows only one axis, oppressor against oppressed. The exact nature of the crime committed becomes secondary as long as the accused wears the right ideological uniform. And before these speakers who come to preach the sanctity of the knife, a young audience applauds, theorizing violence with the lightness of those whose material comfort allows them to romanticize barbarism.
Everything might be less serious if hatred did not also feed on indifference.
That of the ordinary man, who prefers, in the face of the return of Judeophobia, to change the subject rather than break with his social tribe. He has neither doctrine to defend nor hatred to proclaim. He only knows that certain truths can cost a spoiled dinner or a friendship.
So he remains silent, or worse, he weakly nods when someone talks about context, because context is a politeness owed to those he still socializes with on Saturday night.
Thus, a young girl can watch killers in hang gliders, in the Paris metro, without a single muscle in her face betraying the slightest horror.
She did not invent this gaze. It was crafted for her, patiently, through inverted words, shouted anathemas, software that digests crime before she has had time to see it naked, and dinners where no one wanted to spoil dessert. She is the culmination of gathered cowardices.
The cowardice of the mind can disguise itself as courage as long as it finds, in front, enough tepid cowardices to applaud it or to remain silent. The day this silence breaks, and it will break, only a crime among many others will remain bare.
C. Y.
(*) Member of Parliament for the 8th constituency of French citizens living abroad.
Fancy reading all the articles?
Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.