From Sarkozy to Nuñez: the futile idea of ‘organizing the Muslim faith’

"Some tried it", to quote the famous line from Régis Laspalès. In the early 2000s, Nicolas Sarkozy, then Minister of the Interior, tried to "organize the Muslim faith" and it was a resounding failure. The current Minister of the Interior, Laurent Nuñez, is trying to "organize the Muslim faith". Does the Ministry of the Interior not have a memory? Does the minister not have an advisor on Islam? Is there no one to explain to the minister, to the ministry that there are no structures and hierarchy in Islam?

By Christophe Rivière

Published on 23 September 2026

From Sarkozy to Nuñez: the futile idea of ‘organizing the Muslim faith’

Laurent Nuñez dismissed "the criticisms" with a wave of his hand.

In 2002-2003, Minister of the Interior Nicolas Sarkozy invested heavily in an initiative he had launched, that of “organizing the Muslim faith”.

We saw the result. He may have even significantly contributed to worsening the situation regarding Islam in France, with more disputes, going beyond the religious aspect to enter the political arena, particularly with the influences of the Algerian and Moroccan governments on the mosques. Worse, this attempt to take control of the Islamic religion did not prevent the spread of Islamism in general and the development of the entryism of the Muslim Brotherhood trend. And, above all, the attacks.

Despite all this, twenty years later, the Ministry of the Interior is doing it again and digging up the skeleton of the defunct initiative from Sarkozy’s time. What is being created is called the Forum of Islam in France.

In Islam, there are no intermediaries between the believer and their god

The members of this reflection body, set up in 2022, met yesterday at the headquarters of the Ministry of the Interior. Behind the scenes, many believe that the work is “stalled”.

Laurent Nuñez dismissed “the criticisms from those who said it would never work or from those who said ‘what’s the point’ or from those for whom it never goes fast enough or from those who question its legitimacy”. In fact, all “those” who said all this are right.

It is enough to know just a little about Islam to understand that there are no structures, no hierarchy in this religion. Thus, it is futile to try to organize it into structures and with governing bodies. In Islam, there are no intermediaries between the believer and their god.

Ch. R.

Fancy reading all the articles?

Unlock all articles straight away. No obligation.

Subscription

Unlock all articles straight away.

Subscribe

Newsletter

Receive the top headlines every week

Sign up
Activer les notifications OK Non